Hercules aircraft could be the secret weapon that sees off Italian firm’s £20m wind farm

PUBLISHED: 10:31 30 March 2012

Outside RAF Mildenhall at dusk, and shows a USAF AC-130 Hercules landing into the sunset.

Outside RAF Mildenhall at dusk, and shows a USAF AC-130 Hercules landing into the sunset.


A WEST Norfolk village is hoping Hercules aircraft could see off a threat by Italians to build a £20million, 11-turbine wind farm.

The Ministry of Defence believes the turbines, up to 127 metres high, north of Terrington St Clement pose a serious threat to low flying and essential training in the area.

Claire Duddy, assistant safeguarding officer for wind energy at the MoD, said: “The turbines will be within a low flying area and will unacceptably affect military activities.”

She said low flying areas were tactically important “within which military fast jets and Hercules aircraft may operate to as little as 30 metres separation from the ground and other obstacles.

“The proliferation of obstacles within this area is not only a safety hazard but also severely impacts on its utilisation for essential low flying training.”

Some of the comments made to West Norfolk Council

“THE UK/US military sometimes run low-flying night manoeuvres using live munitions i.e. guided bombs and missiles at the nearby bombing range.”

“I CONSIDER any community gains offered by the developer, including those offered to houses in closest proximity to the turbines, will be far outweighed by all the ongoing significant impacts.”

“THE view of 11 wind turbines in close proximity (the nearest wind turbine will only be approx 800m from my house) and the associated concerns regarding noise, shadow flicker and interference with telecommunication signals will significantly reduce my enjoyment of living in this area.”

“THE relationship between wind turbines and health issues such as heart disease, vertigo & tinnitus is well documented. Even more so when the turbines are in close proximity to the public, as seems the case here.”

“IF a person travelled around the coast from Lowestoft to Ongar Hill, the only place where they WOULD NOT see a wind turbine would be the journey’s end at Ongar Hill. Please don’t spoil it.”

“ALL in all I think these turbines will be a benefit to the community as a whole, the construction phase is a small price to pay.”

“I HAD a chat to some of the people living in close proximity and they were quite happy with them although some did say they were glad when the construction was over. All in all I think the will be a benefit to the community as a whole, the construction phase is a small price to pay.”

“ELEVEN turbines is a lot. They are an eyesore and would be better suited further out of the village.”

The turbines could also have implications for radar systems at RAF Marham, RAF Cottesmore, RAF Cranwell, RAF Waddington, RAF Coningsby and RAF Lakenheath.

Ms Duddy said: “These effects include the densensitisation of radar in the vicinity of the turbines and the creation of ‘false’ aircraft returns which air traffic controllers must treat as real.”

This could lead to aircraft not being detected by radar and therefore not presented to air traffic controllers, she added.

The MoD objections are among those lodged against the wind farm proposals put forward by Italian owned Falck Renewables. It claims substantial access amendments have been made following public consultation.

More than 50 objections have been put to West Norfolk Council just four years after Notus Energy of Germany finally gave up the ghost and withdrew its £40million scheme for 19 wind turbines in another Fenland village, at Marshland St James.

That application was marred with tragedy when farmer Richard Herbert, one of a consortium of landowners wanting to build the turbines, drowned himself after protests about the proposals mounted.

Falck says a wind farm in this area “would contribute towards meeting both national and local objectives for the increased use of renewable energy, help reduce the country’s dependence on fossil fuel imports and assist in the efforts being made to reduce the potential effects of climate change.”

The developers have agreed to give £10,000 a year to community schemes if plans are approved.

If you value what this story gives you, please consider supporting the Wisbech Standard. Click the link in the orange box above for details.

Become a supporter

This newspaper has been a central part of community life for many years. Our industry faces testing times, which is why we're asking for your support. Every contribution will help us continue to produce local journalism that makes a measurable difference to our community.

Latest from the Wisbech Standard