Axing Shape Your Place community website will save county council £180,000 a year - but not all users are happy with the decision

15:21 28 February 2015

Shape Your Place, Fenland

Shape Your Place, Fenland's online voice

Archant

Closure of the Cambridgeshire County Council community website Shape Your Place will save council tax payers £180,000 over the next 12 months.

The figure was revealed by the council as it prepares to axe the website on March 25 and to stop taking comments and messages on it from March 2.

“The 2014-15 budget for Shape Your Place was £179, 695,” said a council spokesman. “The expenditure for 2014-15 will be less than the amount budgeted due to reductions in staff hours, reduction in management costs and not filling jobs as they became vacant.”

The council also revealed that once the website closes “unfortunately its content will no longer be available”.

The decision to axe Shape Your Place has met with mixed response from its users and regular contributors.

Wisbech, for instance, where it started – thanks to central Government funding- 14 comments, mostly critical, have been posted on line.

Next are Chatteris with 10 comments, March with six and Huntingdon with one comment.

However not a single comment – pro or anti- has been posted to the Cambridge, Ely. Soham, St Ives or South Cambridgeshire Shape Your Place sites.

The county council said it had asked local councils if they wished to pay to keep Shape Your Place but no financial offers had been received.

“The council has to find £30 million in savings this coming year after having already cut £100 million over the last three years,” said a spokesman.

The council says Shape Your Place has been “highly successful with in excess of 246,000 visitors who have made well over half a million visits”.

However the council adds that “in these austere times we have to focus on what we can and what we cannot continue to deliver”.

Contributors have been generally angry that the site is being axed: one user described it as a site “where you could actually get answers from the relevant authorities”.

Another said: “What a terrible shame. SYP has been a fantastic platform for all sorts of community issues, ideas and knowledge sharing. I think it should be kept up. Some of us would really miss this accessible networking site.”

One reader asked: “What will happen to the archives? If there are photos and videos that have been shared, communities may need more time to set up their own forums and to rescue or retrieve any information shared.”

Fenland district and former Cambridgeshire county councillor Steve Tierney wrote on Shape Your Place: “The end of this site has been on the cards for some time. ‘Austerity’ is not the cause – the site started during ‘austerity’ and its budget grew during austerity, because at that point the council recognised the value in a public forum where people could express views and report problems and have ideas, under the umbrella of local authorities.

“But the site was doomed when control of county council was taken by a rainbow coalition and when the committee system was introduced.”

Another user claimed that “shutting this site was not to save money; it was done to shut the public up”.

One other wrote that it was “one very sad day coming up, it will be missed. Let’s hope that the money saved will be used for protecting the vulnerable, roads etc, and not swallowed up in some bank account in Cambridge.”

4 comments

  • Cambs County Council are very happy to have the lions share of the council tax, and then tell local districts what to do, and then get stroppy if anyone criticises them. You see they think they are the best, know it all, and every local district should listen to them. It would be better to dissolve this council and send the money back locally to local authorities. Perhaps it is time to look carefully at all County Councils and decided if they are really needed. Surely they are just another layer of waste?

    Report this comment

    daveb123

    Monday, March 2, 2015

  • My comment on Shape Your Place was deleted. I was one of the first to write about the closure and I wasn't rude or unpleasant. I gave my opinion as to why Cambridgeshire County Council costs us all so much to run. Obviously I upset someone because it never saw the light of day. I said the real problem is that councillors have little power to control the administration. They talk the talk but don't walk the walk. The unmanageable size and umpteen layers of bureaucracy that forms Cambridgeshire County Council is the real problem. There are far too many well-paid managers managing managers, all with their little "empires", and far too few frontline staff of which the majority are poorly paid and under-funded. £180,000 a year to run a relatively low usage website is an excellent example of the profligacy. They spend our money like water and have the cheek to tell us they do a good job.

    Report this comment

    A Wisbech Voice

    Monday, March 2, 2015

  • How in God's name can it cost £180,000 a year to run a relatively low usage website? I find it absolutely staggering that councils can manage to spend at least ten times as much as anyone else to do even the most basic of jobs! Seriously they really can't have a clue how to run and adminster a website efficiantly if it even cost as much as £18,000 per year...

    Report this comment

    ChrisU

    Sunday, March 1, 2015

  • I would agree that closing this site is being done to shut the (dissatisfied) public up. Its about the only place where it was possible to communicate effectively with the Council Would Cambridgeshire County Council like to tell us how we should make our view known once this site closes? Or is the council just not interested? Perhaps if the council concentrated on maintaining useful services (such as the shape your place website and recycling centres - due to be cut I believe) instead of installing low utilisation cycleways, 20 mph speed limits throughout Cambridge etc it would be able to keep services that people actually want going. We keep having annual 2% increases in council tax - where has that gone?

    Report this comment

    Skipper

    Saturday, February 28, 2015

The views expressed in the above comments do not necessarily reflect the views of this site

More news stories

Yesterday, 16:10
Littleport Level Crossing. Littleport, Cambridgeshire

MP Steve Barclay spoke today of the possibility of “significant local disruption” if Network Rail presses ahead with closing 11 level crossings in NE Cambs.

Yesterday, 23:05
Station road, Manea. Development. Picture: Steve Williams

Developers struggling to find a housing association willing to take four affordable homes in Manea off their hands – being built as part of the original contract- believe they have found a solution.

Yesterday, 16:29
Facet charity shop revamp, Chatteris. Manager Louise Bryan. Picture: Steve Williams.

Vintage meets shabby chic at a shop in Chatteris that has been treated to a step back in time make over.

Yesterday, 14:19
Sacked as governance committee chairman Kit Owen

Five times mayor of March, Councillor Kit Owen, confirmed today he had been sacked as chairman of the committee responsible for overseeing the financial performance of Fenland District Council.

Most read stories

HOT JOBS

Show Job Lists

Digital Edition

Image
Read the Wisbech Standard e-edition E-edition

Newsletter Sign Up